Why Divinity Candy Is the One Thing We Make by the Forecast

Divinity is the only candy in our kitchen that gets rescheduled. We do not make it in July. We do not make it during a rainstorm, and in Ferndale in November there are a fair number of those. When a batch is on the books, I check the humidity before I check anything else, because divinity candy will tell on you. Make it on a wet morning and you get sticky puddles that never set. Make it on a dry one and you get the thing it is supposed to be, a cloud with a thin shell that cracks when you bite it.

The recipe is not complicated. Sugar, water, and corn syrup go into a pan and cook to the hard ball stage, around 260 degrees. Then the syrup goes in a thin stream into stiffly beaten egg whites while the mixer runs, and you keep beating until the whole thing goes from glossy to dull and starts holding the shape of the beater. We drop it by the spoonful onto paper and leave it alone. Three ingredients, plus vanilla, plus nuts if you want them. There is nothing in it but sugar and air and patience.

Divinity candy is an American invention, an early twentieth century one. Corn syrup was new and cheap and being pushed hard at home cooks, and the company behind Karo put divinity recipes in its pamphlets right alongside everything else. Food historians trace a milk based version to around 1907 and the version most of us would recognize to a 1915 recipe. Nobody actually knows where the name came from. The best guess is that somebody took a bite and said the word out loud. Swap the white sugar for brown and you get a darker candy called sea foam. Add pecans, the way Southern cooks did, and it turns into a Christmas staple down there.

The reason it is fussy is the same reason hard candy goes sticky in summer. Sugar pulls moisture out of the air. A meringue type candy is mostly air held inside a sugar web, so when the air is wet the surface takes on water, the sugar starts to dissolve, and the structure sags before it ever sets. There is no fixing it afterward. You can only pick your day.

We usually have divinity in the case through the holidays, made in the morning when the forecast looks kind, in half pound and one pound boxes. If you have only ever had the store bought kind, ours is softer in the middle and shatters a little at the edge. Divinity does not keep in the refrigerator either, so leave the box on the counter and eat it within a couple weeks, which in my experience is not a hard rule to follow.